Ndokwa Vanguard News

News at your finger tips

Ndokwa Vanguard News

News at your finger tips

Politics

Atiku, the ADC and a Script Nigeria Has Seen Before

By Ekene Aninze, Esq.

Nigerian politics has a disturbing habit of repeating its worst chapters. Sometimes, the names change, the political parties change, and the circumstances appear different, but the underlying problems remain remarkably familiar.

Former Vice President Atiku Abubakar, whose presidential ambition has once again become entangled in litigation, is facing a legal and political predicament that bears striking similarities to what happened to him and the Action Congress (AC) in 2007.

Almost twenty years later, Nigeria appears to be confronting another situation in which litigation over a presidential candidate’s eligibility and the internal affairs of a political party threatens to disrupt the electoral process.

The question is whether the country has learnt anything from its previous experience.

The 2007 Experience

In 2007, Atiku Abubakar fell out with President Olusegun Obasanjo. According to Atiku, the disagreement was largely rooted in his opposition to the proposed constitutional amendment that would have allowed President Obasanjo to seek a third term in office.

Following the political disagreement, Atiku left the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and joined the Action Congress, which subsequently nominated him as its presidential candidate for the 2007 general election.

However, his political difficulties soon assumed a legal dimension.

In December 2006, following investigations by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and a subsequent Federal Government administrative panel of inquiry, Atiku was indicted over allegations of corruption. The Federal Government accepted the panel’s findings and published its position in a White Paper.

Relying on the indictment and the provisions of Section 137(1)(i) of the 1999 Constitution, INEC excluded Atiku from its list of presidential candidates for the 2007 election, notwithstanding that the Action Congress had submitted his name in accordance with Section 32(1) of the Electoral Act 2006.

The exclusion generated a legal battle that eventually reached the Supreme Court.

The Federal High Court, in its judgment of March 7, 2007, held that INEC lacked the power to disqualify candidates on its own. However, the Court of Appeal, in a judgment delivered by Justice Umaru Faruk Abdullahi, reversed that position and held that INEC possessed the authority to screen candidates and exclude those who failed to satisfy the constitutional requirements.

Dissatisfied with the decision, the Action Congress and Atiku approached the Supreme Court in Action Congress v. INEC, SC.69/2007.

On April 16, 2007, just five days before the presidential election scheduled for April 21, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal and held that INEC had no power to disqualify Atiku from contesting the election on the basis of the administrative indictment.

The court’s position was significant. An administrative panel’s indictment was not the same thing as a conviction by a court of law. Equally important, INEC could not assume powers of disqualification beyond those conferred on it by the Constitution and the Electoral Act.

However, while the Supreme Court eventually settled the legal question in Atiku’s favour, the timing of the decision created serious logistical difficulties for INEC.

Ballot papers had already been printed without Atiku’s name. Following the Supreme Court’s decision, INEC had to arrange for fresh presidential ballot papers to be printed in South Africa and transported to Nigeria within an extremely short period.

The exercise created enormous logistical pressure, affected the distribution of electoral materials and contributed to delays in the commencement of voting.

That was the unfortunate consequence of allowing a dispute over a presidential candidate to remain unresolved until practically the eve of an election.

The 2026 Judgment

Fast-forward to 2026, and Nigeria is once again witnessing a legal controversy surrounding Atiku Abubakar’s presidential ambition.

On November 5, 2026, Justice Peter O. Lifu of the Federal High Court, Abuja, delivered judgment in Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/1819/2025, instituted by Nafiu Bala Gombe against the African Democratic Congress (ADC) and others.

The suit challenged the legitimacy of the leadership structure that emerged under the leadership of Senator David Mark and the process through which that leadership was constituted.

In its judgment, the court nullified the emergence of the David Mark-led National Working Committee and the decisions taken under the disputed leadership, including the emergence of Rauf Aregbesola as National Secretary.

The judgment also affected the political decisions and activities undertaken by the disputed leadership, including the process that produced Atiku Abubakar as the ADC’s presidential candidate for the 2027 general election.

This is particularly significant because, before the judgment, the ADC had already conducted its presidential primary, nominated Atiku, selected former Minister of Transportation, Rotimi Amaechi, as his running mate and uploaded their particulars to INEC’s nomination portal.

Consequently, a judgment concerning the internal leadership structure of a political party has now placed the party’s presidential ticket and its preparations for the 2027 election in serious uncertainty.

However, beyond the immediate consequences for Atiku and the ADC, there is another important legal question that deserves attention.

In July 2026, Justice Musa Liman of the Federal High Court, Abuja, delivered judgment in a separate suit instituted by Leke Abejide, upholding the David Mark-led leadership of the ADC and dismissing the challenge to its emergence.

The existence of that judgment raises questions about judicial consistency and the relationship between decisions of courts of coordinate jurisdiction.

The established position of Nigerian law is that a court of coordinate jurisdiction cannot sit on appeal over the decision of another court of equal jurisdiction. Where a subsisting judgment has determined an issue between parties, another court must exercise caution before making a decision that effectively contradicts it.

Nevertheless, whether the July judgment and the November judgment involved the same parties, issues and subject matter, and the precise legal effect of the earlier decision on the later proceedings, are matters that must be carefully examined by the appellate courts.

The ADC has rejected the November judgment and indicated its intention to challenge it on appeal. The appellate court will therefore have an important responsibility in determining the legal questions arising from the proceedings.

The Cost of Judicial Delay

One of the greatest lessons from the 2007 experience is that a judgment, even when legally correct, can create enormous electoral complications when delivered too close to an election.

The problem is not necessarily that courts should refrain from entertaining disputes involving political parties or candidates. Courts are constitutionally empowered to determine disputes brought before them in accordance with the law.

However, the timing of electoral litigation is just as important as the eventual outcome.

A political party that is uncertain about the legitimacy of its leadership, the validity of its primary election or the status of its candidates cannot effectively organise a national campaign.

Its financial commitments become uncertain, its campaign structures are weakened, and its supporters are left wondering whether the candidates they intend to vote for will eventually appear on the ballot.

INEC is equally affected.

The Commission must work within an electoral timetable that requires it to finalise nominations, prepare ballot papers, organise logistics and distribute electoral materials across the country.

Where litigation concerning the leadership or candidates of a political party remains unresolved until the final stages of electoral preparations, the Commission may find itself caught between competing legal obligations and administrative deadlines.

This was precisely the kind of logistical difficulty witnessed in 2007 when the Supreme Court’s decision on Atiku’s candidature came just five days before the presidential election.

Nigeria should not have to experience the same difficulties again before appreciating the importance of timely judicial intervention.

Conclusion

The circumstances surrounding the 2007 exclusion of Atiku Abubakar and the present controversy involving the ADC are not identical. The legal questions, the parties involved and the applicable electoral framework are different.

Nevertheless, they share one disturbing similarity: a major presidential candidature has become entangled in litigation capable of disrupting the electoral process.

The courts must be allowed to determine the disputes before them without political interference. At the same time, the appellate courts should recognise the urgency of electoral matters and ensure that these disputes are resolved within a timeframe that does not undermine the preparations for the 2027 general election.

The lesson of 2007 should not be lost on us.

An election should be determined by the votes of Nigerians, not by avoidable judicial and administrative uncertainty that leaves political parties struggling to establish who their candidates are when the election is already approaching.

Justice must be done, but in electoral matters, it must also be done in time.

Ekene Aninze, Esq. is a legal practitioner, writer and political analyst based in Nigeria.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *